29 Comments
User's avatar
Michelle Jordan's avatar

Republicans have no monopoly over faith or religion. If Democrats want to talk about their faith or what motivates them to run for public office then more power to them. What it is not about is forcing it on others much like Christian nationalists want to force their faith and their ideology down our throats. JD is NO authority on what being a Christian is about. He will turn everyone off.

Arkansas Blue's avatar

Vance is the typical catholic convert: once converted, they are holier than the pope.

KnockKnockGreenpeace's avatar

And I am a typical ex-Catholic. It's easier to see the pros and cons from the outside, and I won't be going back!

KnockKnockGreenpeace's avatar

I long for a day when religion has no traction in this country's political conversation. This would give us the space to act on what's best for all Americans, in a humanitarian sense. We SHOULD want to do right by people. At least, atheists know this.

Your faith is personal. Keep it to yourself.

Arkansas Blue's avatar

Absolutely. I've come to know most atheists are better people. They do more for their neighbors, they donate more to good causes, they participate in more food drives and on and on.

Dennis's avatar

I'm sick and tired of hearing anything to do with religion being interwoven with governance or politics period. If someone wants to be religious have at it but I don't want to hear about it. "Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by the rulers as useful."

David's avatar

There is a great meme with Maggie Smith's face:

"My dear, religion is like a penis. It is a perfectly fine thing for one to have and take pride in, but one takes it out and waves it in my face we have a problem."

Dennis's avatar

Ha! Thank you for that!

Keith E Davis's avatar

So no Christian, or for that matter a Jew, or Muslim, or a follower of any religion can ever serve in a public office? Does that mean only atheists and agnostics can serve the public good? We all are influenced by a belief system, but why are some beliefs not acceptable when others are?

Dennis's avatar

I'm not at all saying that and surely to goodness you're smart enough to get it. I don't care what religion a politician believes and they can talk about it all they want in their place of worship, their home, with friends etc. but not as a part of their political discourse. I honestly don't know why that concept was so difficult for you

Keith E Davis's avatar

Dennis Thanks for your comments. I get your point, but I am sure that leaving one’s belief system

Out of the aspects of life is impossible. No matter what we think or believe in, they define our behavior and actions. So to have a follower of Jesus Christ forgo the Lord’s teachings in the political arena negates the reason to be a public servant. I think that’s lot of the so called “Christians” today are really not, hence the dichotomy between their words and actions.

KnockKnockGreenpeace's avatar

Do you hear atheists trumpet our belief systems? I also do not wish to hear what should be your private, inner thoughts. Surely everyone has secular beliefs.

Nona Faurnonce's avatar

Albert Einstein was also religious.

Dennis's avatar

That's a bit of a stretch to say he was religious in the usual sense of the word

Nona Faurnonce's avatar

Didn't I just say that I've noticed people vary in how they define religious faith and what they expect from it? Einstein was very religious, but he liked to say that religion can be based on different things -- and unfortunately (he said) within each religion you can find all those different things. Einstein believed in what he called cosmic religious feeling. He was a good Jewish boy but he looked for God as expressed in the awesome order of the universe.

Nona Faurnonce's avatar

Francis Collins, American geneticist and former director of NIH, was deeply religious. Mostly he kept that to himself, but he was asked a few times to explain why he did not see a conflict between religious faith and science. He didn't, of course. So, it's not true that old saying. I have noticed that how people define religious faith and what they expect from it can vary a lot. I know of at least one anthropologist who took the kids to church because she saw religion as a necessary part of human culture -- and culture as the chief survival tool of the human race.

Noah Dowd's avatar

With regards to Adam Hamilton, a second Republican former governor of Kansas has endorsed the Democrat Adam Hamilton over Republican Roger Marshall for the US Senate. https://www.msn.com/en-us/tv/news/another-republican-ex-governor-of-kansas-endorses-democrat-in-tight-senate-race/ar-AA2dtAHK

ev`'s avatar

I am not at all religious, but it's about time people who claim to "walk the walk" step up and model the positive aspects of their "faith."

KnockKnockGreenpeace's avatar

If they want to shout about, they'd better model it in person.

Nancy K's avatar

What happened to “separation of church and state ?” Using “Christianity “ to excuse bad behavior is wrong. I happen to be a recovering Catholic. I believe a bunch of old men wrote the stories in the bible based on their opinions. It’s a story book. What is missing in our society is teaching ethics-humanity-and human decency.

Carol Navarrete's avatar

Having been a teenager on the cusp of the 1960s/70s, there was moaning about how America's youth was drifting away from the church, with, apparently, the Liberals instigating the exodus. Churches countered with more youth-friendly additions to services such as guitars, or in extreme cases, local rock bands. But the roots of the dissatisfaction, or more accurately, the disillusion were left unaddressed. The 1741 Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God sermon may have been effective for a century and a half or so, - my mother once commented that growing up in a straight-laced, Norwegian Lutheran community, attending Sunday service meant watching her mother cry - but once the flood of fear abated, the ugly stains of hypocrisy, denominational infighting and corruption of various varieties and degrees became evident. The world grew smaller and it became obvious that the good people we met who were Moslem, Hindu, Indigenous or atheist were not going to be cast into hell, leaving only our own discrete brand of spirituality standing alone as a shining city on a hill. You were right to point out the aspect of the Parable of the Good Samaritan that doesn't receive enough attention. The audience Jesus was addressing was made up of Jews, but it was not the Parable of the Good Jew. The hero wasn't "one of us." It was someone who was an "other." Given a choice, a lot of us chose the other.

Cindy Terrify's avatar

No politicians should be talking about religion. If Democrats have to talk about religion (only because the Republicans talk about how Christian they are) they should be talking about how the Republicans call themselves Christians but everything they do says the opposite.

ev`'s avatar

Yeah, in a perfect world. But, unfortunately, superstition still abounds among humans.

Cindy's avatar

There have been faithful Democrats in Washington for years. I think what's drawing attention here is that these are white Democrats. Once again, activists of the Christian faith who are not white don't get as much attention: looking at you, Raphael Warnock and Emanuel Cleaver. Thank you for this article!

Lenny Rothbart's avatar

So we’ve reached a point where we admit we need all the help we can get? Good! Better than being cocky, as we were in 2024. We could definitely stand to learn some humility (not easy, but easier to take than humiliation). Hopefully we’ve learned our lesson & won’t alienate potential allies who agree with us on a couple of points just because they won’t embrace the entire platform. I’m glad to hear all the encouraging news recently, but let’s not kid ourselves — we could still blow this, as we have in the past (Bernie, anyone?). Snatching defeat from the jaws of victory is our special talent.

Al Draycott's avatar

I personally try to show my faith, not by words but by actions. I don't, for one minute, believe these so-called Christian Nationalists. They seem to spout off about the word but don't seem to follow the gospel. Their particular actions speak volumes.

David's avatar

No, we just don't walk around waiving fake "Christianity" in everyone's faces while telling anyone not Christian they will go to hell.