76 Comments
User's avatar
Sharon L. Shelly's avatar

Ohio is one of a number of states that have been governed by a Republican "trifecta" for years. The GOP has held the governorship and both houses of the legislature. They have come to feel completely entitled to do whatever they want, regardless of the will of the voters.

I think this helps explain why Jon Husted is bewildered by the backlash to his beloved data centers. And why he thought that introducing a pathetic bill to "suggest" that data centers "consider" some (strictly voluntary) regulations might be enough to mollify Ohioans. He has no real understanding of the real concerns of his state's voters.

Bob Kroshefsky's avatar

And, being an Ohio citizen, I am anxiously awaiting the verdict of the people on November 3rd.

Daniel Solomon's avatar

The BIG ISSUE in Ohio is corruption. Husted should have been charged in the First Energy case. He also can be connected to the EPSTEIN coverup via political contributions.

The local media is horrible. Should be picketed, boycotted for failing to report on Trump's insanity. Republican corruption.

Alyn Harrison's avatar

And let’s not forget John Kasich, as governor decades ago, granted the big tech companies a 40 year tax abatement! Bad idea then and worse idea now.

LiverpoolFCfan's avatar

"Data centers may not be the top issue in Ohio or nationally, but they have come to serve as a stand-in for a host of issues — affordability, the outsized power of high-tech companies, soaring energy issues, Trump’s utter cluelessness, Republicans’ inability to cross their cult leader on issues that matter to constituents, and the looming divide between the rich and everyone else. "

LOVE that Ms. Rubin relegates "Trump's cluelessness" into the middle of a long list of trespasses that the megalomaniac's (or maybe that should be "MAGAlomaniac") government has imposed upon our once-great country.

Can't wait for a time in which the fascist felon's name is barely mentioned at all, or only in the context of "disgraced former president".

Arkansas Blue's avatar

I fully agree with you. If I never see his picture or his name in any context again, it will not be soon enough. Or hear his voice brrrrrrr!

Chris Dortch's avatar

The Democrats may be getting outspent on political ads, but that simpleton Trump has evened the score and then some. Everywhere he speaks, he says something counter to a coherent political message and so insane (LA and San Diego expendable in a war with Iran?!) that Democrats have free ads provided by the grifter in chief himself. Keep traveling Donnie! And as Jen stated, you can’t keep your trap shut, so keep tossing your ill-informed, demented ideas against the wall. They won’t stick, but collectively they’re going to lead to your political neutering when the Democrats take back over Congress.

Stephen Brady's avatar

The best neutralizer of rethuglican advertising is the Idiot in Chief himself.

Gaye Mara's avatar

“Rethuglican”—love it!

Steve 218's avatar

Well said. The LA/SanDiego pronouncement was language that should never have come out of a president's mouth. The man is demented. The White House mouth (Steven Cheung) is now whingeing that we're taking it out of context. That won't stick to the wall either. We know what we heard. Trump is a walking, talking billboard for Democrats.

CharlesI's avatar

Trump’s brain and mouth are out of control. He is the best ad for a Democratic takeover of both Houses. "Go Don, Go!!!"

Andan Casamajor's avatar

They say he's going to do 37 campaign events over 30 days. That sounds like a formula for exhaustion, confusion, gaffes, insults and so much clickable, quotable Trumpism that the Democrats won't need a pile of campaign cash. Keep talking, Piggy.

Jason's avatar

Unfortunately the data center issue isn’t an all around slam dunk for Democrats, as it should be.

In Wisconsin, the abjectly awful GOP candidate Tom Tiffany is pummeling Dem candidate David Crowley on this, who has said he wanted Wisconsin to “become an AI and a data hub, not only for the entire country, but for the entire globe”, a deeply tone deaf position in a state that hates data centers. (Francesca Hong supported a moratorium).

Hakeem Jeffries, in his typical middling, noncommittal style, has said “that a moratorium is “not a position that I’ve articulated at this moment” “, and won’t support anything other than tepid regulations.

Recent surveys have shown the GOP and Dems neck and neck regarding AI generally. The Democratic Party has a lot of work to do here.

Jason's avatar

Charles Schumer has also supported increased data center construction, saying only they should “pay their fair share” and only offering weak and vague regulations.

His daughter now works for OpenAI.

Democrats from Josh Shapiro to JB Pritzker to Gretchen Whitmer all supported data center construction until very recently. As is so often the case, the progressive wing of the party was ahead of the curve on this.

Daniel Solomon's avatar

So...you support Republicans? You oppose Shapiro?

Jason's avatar

Yes, that’s exactly what I said, thanks for the brilliant commentary.

Steve 218's avatar

Data centers are going to be the new aircraft carriers on the ground -- very large targets, and they have less protection. Carriers are sent out with a strike force for defense. There is no "golden dome" over data centers; they will be at risk and residents in the area around them will be collateral targets.

Jason's avatar

There’s all true, but of course these data centers are even worse. The environmental damage from these beasts is still being understated.

Steve 218's avatar

In some cases, this understatement is not totally known; in other, it's intentional. Cutting down trees, paving over arable land and creating heat islands does not sound good for the environment, not to mention the depletion of water resources and the extra pollution created for powering these monstrosities.

Jason's avatar

I’ve read accounts of the maddening noise pollution too.

Anne Pierce's avatar

As usual, Shakespeare said it first and best, in Hamlet: "...For 'tis the sport to have the enginer

Hoist with his own petard;...." This is what the Republican party asked for when they nominated Trump a third time, even though by then he had multiple felony convictions and a civil judgement for abuse.

Gary Anderson's avatar

After nearly two years of feeling frustrated and fearful of the direction of our country, statements like this “The result may be a stunning shift in Ohio from red to blue in just two years. And if that is where Ohio is heading, a state Trump won by 11 points in 2024, then we are heading for a historic blue wave.” give me cause for hope. The American voting public has been slow to wake up to the reality but, once awake, is likely to exact retribution in the form of new public servants.

Bob Kroshefsky's avatar

Unfortunately, the majority of Americans care little or pay attention when things happen to other people; e.g., illegal deportations, ICE murders, floods and fires, being collateral damage in a war, but affect their pocketbooks and, as Johnny Carson would say when playing TV pitchman Art Fern, "Boy, do we care!"

Kim's avatar

It’s always about the money.

Michelle Jordan's avatar

Our moron senator Tommy Tuberville goes right along with the orange felon. Tuberville has no integrity whatsoever. He has been bought out by data center moguls to the tune of $25K. I hope our electorate has more sense than to vote for this hideous piece of work. Most Republicans are totally out of touch when it comes to the needs of their constituents. I hope a blue tsunami comes cresting very soon.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

Tuberville also has no intelligence whatsoever.

Thomas Moore's avatar

Yes, data centers stand in for a host of issues that Americans are mad about, and in particular the lack of accountability by the tech bros for all of the problems they've caused us and the misuse of our personal data. And not only the tech bros, but the oligarchy in general. We want their money out of our politics, and we want them to pay a lot more in taxes. And they aren't going to go along with those things without a fight.

Jean Oristano's avatar

Anything that exposes the GOP Politicians’ collective Greed and damages them in the vote is just fine with me. If the entire country goes blue, I’m here for it.

Violet Cauthon's avatar

"Collective greed" - best one-word description of the current GOP/trump I've ever read!

Leigh Horne's avatar

Let's keep banging the drum on this issue, because it so well illustrates the callous and extractive agenda of the Billionaire Class as a whole and the rapacious AI industry in most recently. Extraction has been a means used by the petrochemical and mining industries for, well, hundreds of years in many cases. You might want to look abroad at what's happened in colonial as well as current times. Big companies come in, extract the goodies (oil, minerals, gas), degrade the environment, deplete the natural environment of water and soil, cause significant and widespread health issues (cancer, black lung) in the local population while they're extracting goods (in AI this includes the intellectual property of everyone) and polluting the evironment, then pull up stakes and leave the damage behind. Another word for extraction might well be rape---yet another good example of the mindset of those who think that the only thing that matters is getting richer. These men have NO conscience and NO care for us or the earth we all live on. The jury is in and they've been found guilty wherever they've gone.

Justin Sayne's avatar

“Donald Trump cannot be persuaded to keep his trap shut.”

Because: there’s no one driving that train. And….he loves the sound of his own voice….even if no one else does.

Stephen Brady's avatar

Data Centers are a bad deal all the way around. They create a heat island for miles around and can create a mini heat dome. One number I saw was an 18 degree increase... we regularly are above 95 degrees on a summer day - I don't want to contemplate what 113 degrees would do to us. We are already pumping too much ground water to irrigate crops because of 4 years+ of drought. Using that water to cool a data center once and then dumping it in a river to end up in the oceans is remarkably stupid. I live out in the country for peace and quiet... you can go on line and listen to how much noise one produces. And maybe one actually employs about 25 people.

S. Elaine Keckley's avatar

There’s on in my area, been there awhile. Is a million sq ft, employees 50. Just astounding to me. Creating jobs? Only for construction.

Pam Birkenfeld's avatar

Thanks for bringing that out, I never heard about the heat dome before. Of course, they are water and electricity sucking monsters, even without that issue.

john A ferguson's avatar

Stephen, I'd wondered how long it would take for the heat island effect that these things have to surface.

As a daily user of the services they provide, I want them to exist, but they certainly should not be in anyone's back yard. Their design and location cry out for intelligent regulation which would address impact on ground water, noise level at property line dependent on proximity to residences, impact on local utility economics to existing customers, receipt of public funding and if so on what basis? Certainly not new job provision.

From a daily cost of operation, a northern Virginia location may look good to their builders, but locations in less populated western states might not be that much more expensive and might have the advantage of reduced permitting delays.

There is also possibilty (don't count on this one) that innovation in their component design and the algorithms that they employ will reduce their size. It als seems possible that there is considerable reduncancy in the entire array of these things such that consolidation might reduce their numbers.

Regulate we must, and I think at least the enabling legistlation must be at the national level hopefull written by a better balanced congress.

Violet Cauthon's avatar

Every tree cut down, every pasture's grass bulldozed and, yes, a "heat sink". I've been ranting about losing trees to these giant boxes for months. Trees help modulate temps; are good for birds and wildlife and human beings. I never hear how those ugly barns will harm wildlife but they will. Yes, certainly the technology will likely reduce the size needed and in the meantime we've scarred our outdoors all over this country.

Bruce Kelley's avatar

Republican candidates in toss of states claim they do not support Trump‘s policies. However, they have actively supported his policies or remained silent in the face of his most egregious acts. If reelected they will do so again.

Hummingbird3's avatar

Anyone with a functioning brain and an attention span longer than that of a gnat should not be fooled by what Repugnicans say now and should always remember they are the reason we are in this situation today and how they supported the confirmation of dangerous idiots, and were silent in the face of extralegal murders and massive corruption. The other thing I hope people remember is that electing a Blue Wave in this midterm may not get us everything we want: trump will still be president with veto power unless it’s a Blue Tsunami giving us a super majority in both chambers of Congress (enough to cancel out the Dem-defectors line John Fetterman and Maria Gluesenkamp Perez) and SCOTUS will largely be intact. But starting aggressive and relentless public investigations into all the illegal actions and corruption, reporting on it everywhere and holding the crooks accountable is very important, do-able and will set the stage for 2028 when we must also win the White House in a landslide.

Jim (Bombguy24)'s avatar

As an Independent living in VA, I will say many Independent's feel, like me, a "Blue Wave" is only as good as the long-term benefit. Will the Dems squander this golden opportunity (as they have in the past), or will they begin to enact real policies that benefit all Americans for years, if not generations, to come. It truly is time for both political party's to start putting America first, not their own self-interest.

Kim Slocum's avatar

Because of the Senate’s operating rules and a corrupt, politicized SCOTUS, Dems will need to clean house thoroughly before doing anything else. Behaving otherwise will lead them into the trap Republicans have already laid for them. We saw this play out during President Biden’s term where most everything he attempted to do was either slow walked in the Senate or declared unconstitutional by the Supremes. Let’s not do that again. Hoping for better behavior out of the GOP is simply not a viable strategy if we really want to save the country.

Milford Sprecher's avatar

Make your voice heard to your electeds.

Jim (Bombguy24)'s avatar

Thank you. I have and will continue to do so. It is not difficult to reach out to your elected officials, as has been posted often in these forums. I encourage everyone to do so.

Pam Birkenfeld's avatar

Well, that’s true, but the problem is people always kick the Democrats out, even though they have improved things. Democrats come in after recessions, improve the economics, and then people forget what the Republicans had done and elect them again, and we are back where we started from. I have seen analysis of this phenomenon over years, and it happens all too often.

Jim (Bombguy24)'s avatar

I agree; and I think, in part, it's because we tend to pass legislation, knowing it's flawed in some respects, without a mechanism to review and update it periodically. I don't mean simple amendments which adds complication and complexity. I'm talking about something like bi-annual, bi-partisan review to improve said legislation, rather than the constant repeal and replace.

Pam Birkenfeld's avatar

That would be ideal but by partisan seems like an impossibility right now.

Ivan Tufaart's avatar

The result may be a stunning shift in Ohio from red to blue in just two years. And if that is where Ohio is heading, a state Trump won by 11 points in 2024, then we are heading for a historic blue wave.

From your keyboard to The Lord's eyes! But Ohio is Ohio, and no matter what the polls say, if I wanted to place a bet or Acton and/or Brown, I'd still want odds.

Alexa Murray's avatar

The results of a fair election increasingly are not in doubt. Elon Musk has just released a large number of unscheduled Star Link modules in the last few weeks set for orbit over the US. Who is monitoring his behavior? I can’t help but think of Stalin’s comment that people who vote don’t matter, only the people who count the vote. I’m not a conspiracy theorist, but his self interest and sociopathy (and his technical abilities) are a matter of public record.

Robert Lastick's avatar

It seems to me that Musk's end should be the same as the end Stalin was fated.

What goesaroundcomesaround.

Alexa Murray's avatar

Hard core, but good. There’s suspicion that he was poisoned by a member of his inner circle, which is the sort of thing that happens when you have the kind of friends he had.