17 Comments
User's avatar
Steve Honley's avatar

"I was irritated by the overall lack of recognition for shows by and about women, especially funny ones." Well said, Meredith. Another striking omission in that category is "The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel."

On a more cheerful note, I look forward to future installments in your new venture!

Robert Kapp's avatar

Un Village Francais should have been included. Also Babylon Berlin.

Anne-Louise Luccarini's avatar

Excellent! The arts column The Contrarian lacked.

Marliss Desens's avatar

In reading the article, I realize just how much I do not watch these days. Other than The Great British Baking Show, which I watched in the beginning years, and Call the Midwife, I don't think I've seen any other programs mentioned. I don't have cable, and I don't do streaming. Unless it is on PBS, I don't watch it. I thought that World on Fire, of which there has been two seasons, did an excellent job of showing the suffering of World War II, although I could have done without the soap opera love triangle. The scenes that have stayed with me are those of the Gestapo breaking the mother of an epileptic daughter, who then kills herself and her daughter rather than let her be "institutionalized," which the mother understood would be killing her. The scene of the British ship sinking is another, as was the desert warfare arc, and the Germans murdering Polish civilians and anyone Jewish. I do not know if there will be a third season. I never understood why the series received no attention from The Washington Post or The New York Times.

Leslie Spotz's avatar

Thanks so much!

Noah Dowd's avatar

You can edit your comments. See the 3 dots to the right of your name? Click on those, and one option will be "edit".

Lisa Jean Walker's avatar

I have been culturally out-of-touch my whole life—I don’t pay attention. Your writing is smart and a delight, and I welcome your newsletter to keep me a tad bit more in the know.

Robert's avatar

I saw the NYT's top 100 TV show list but it was totally irrelevant to me. I'm not interested in the opinions of those who rated them. Perhaps I'm odd, but I have no desire to watch most of what was on their list. Given today's world, why would I want to watch their depressing "artistic or meaningful "shows. I'm glad that some worthy shows that I watch made to the list but were rated far below "meaningful" shows. I'm glad Andor made it to the list but it should have had a higher rating because of its quality acting, story, and relevance to today. However, perhaps because I am a sci-fy fan, there were many other worthy shows that were left off the list, like Silo on Apple TV and The Expanse on Amazon Prime, both are relevant to today. Babylon Five wasn't eligible because it started before 2000 but was the first of its kind and a great story. There is also Apple TV's alternative history of the space race called "For All Mankind" and of course Slow Horses which I believe made the list. The list also didn't include some positive series like "All Creatures Great and Small" on PBS (if you still get and support PBS). Yes. Ted Lasso was fun and different but not perfect. Finally, I forgot to mention "The Chosen" which is an independent show about the ministry of Jesus. I'm a Christian but not a religious fanatic but think that his ministry was mostly told as a history. The lead, Jonathan Roumie deserves an Emmy for his portrayal of Jesus, So, I guess what I'm trying to say is that the list is useless because it doesn't account for different viewer's interests and moods. I won't wast my time on it next year.

John R. Mohn's avatar

“I” is very important to you , but not so impressive to me.