Van Houton should resign. I was a prosecutor in CT for nearly 27 years, 20 of those trying major felonies, including nearly 40 sexual assaults. Making ANY statement to the public about a victim of a crime or their credibility is at minimum a disservice to the public, the law, and the victim. In some jurisdictions, it also is a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct, though as far as I can tell, not in New York. But it is supremely unprofessional, especially when undertaken to cover the failings of the attorney, and made without full knowledge of the facts.
Van Houten, being a district attorney was either reckless or incompetent for not checking to be sure there wasn’t other evidence or reports from Jane Doe before speaking publicly. He has really muddied the water.
If this isn't a typical case of a long line of white males slapping down the little girl, I don't know what is. It's another case of the female not being believed. Awww shucks, the fraternity brothers just wanted to have some fun, isn't that their right? Doesn't the majority of males (no matter what color they are) think that way?
And, of course, the orange convicted felon and all his clan members have made it fashionable again for these things to happen.
Van Houten should be removed from his position. His statements were unprofessional and unwarranted whether or not the case proceeds. NO rape victim would think they could come to this man or his office and receive any support.
One of my initial thoughts, which was also a common theme in lettes to the Times, was about campus police.
Campus police are fine to handle parking violations
They are fine for escorting home students who were studying in the library til midnight and are uneasy about walking a deserted campus alone
They are great to handle uncomplicated drunk and disorderly conduct
They can handle simple cases of vandalism and petty thievery
Maybe they can handle a fist fight between students
But the minute the (alleged or documented) conduct crosses over into something that, if true, would constitute a felony, then they're simply out of their league. They need immediately to refer the case to the city, county or state police-- in this case, to which ever police department has a dedicated sex crime unit.
Wow - thank you so much for your expert insights provided to us here. With so much going on right now I hadn't had the time to learn about this horror at Cornell U. SO MUCH wrong was done to this young woman.🥺😭 Let us hope that we as a society can bring her some sort of comfort. I'm going to share your piece on Facebook. We need to get the clear facts out to the public for the benefit of Jane Doe.
This is a problem for the public whenever there is a criminal investigation.
In general, people want to compartmentalize facts, to form opinions, so they can process and move on, but that is not possible while an investigation is still early and ongoing. Even after, most information will not be widely available to the public.
That is why it is very important for police, prosecutors, and elected officials to be careful in their statements.
An early false impression, given with the weight of authority, is difficult to overcome, even if facts that contradict it are made available.
And the public needs to adjust the expectation of being able to know and form opinions right away.
All women should avoid going to frat houses, especially when intoxicated. There are so many of these incidents occuring in that setting. As far as I'm concerned fraternities are coddled and they should all be shut down.
It was my understanding, maybe in error, that she didn’t remember what had happened until later and to some extent through Snapchat, texts, or other social media exchanged by participants and seen by others. There’s no way she could know exactly what happened. She may have just dissociated like many victims do (as if she wasn’t really there, or it happened to someone else or not at all). Please clear this up for me. It would be that much worse if she learned later from shared social media rather than remembering herself later. Regardless, this will have a lasting effect on her life. I have seen 2 women who identified her rapist, and it went to trial, where the defense attorney tried to present it as her fault. ‘What were you wearing “ and the other accusations made in the body of this essay. Women who know how brutal a trial can be may not report it,
Van Houton should resign. I was a prosecutor in CT for nearly 27 years, 20 of those trying major felonies, including nearly 40 sexual assaults. Making ANY statement to the public about a victim of a crime or their credibility is at minimum a disservice to the public, the law, and the victim. In some jurisdictions, it also is a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct, though as far as I can tell, not in New York. But it is supremely unprofessional, especially when undertaken to cover the failings of the attorney, and made without full knowledge of the facts.
Van Houten, being a district attorney was either reckless or incompetent for not checking to be sure there wasn’t other evidence or reports from Jane Doe before speaking publicly. He has really muddied the water.
If this isn't a typical case of a long line of white males slapping down the little girl, I don't know what is. It's another case of the female not being believed. Awww shucks, the fraternity brothers just wanted to have some fun, isn't that their right? Doesn't the majority of males (no matter what color they are) think that way?
And, of course, the orange convicted felon and all his clan members have made it fashionable again for these things to happen.
Van Houten should be removed from his position. His statements were unprofessional and unwarranted whether or not the case proceeds. NO rape victim would think they could come to this man or his office and receive any support.
One of my initial thoughts, which was also a common theme in lettes to the Times, was about campus police.
Campus police are fine to handle parking violations
They are fine for escorting home students who were studying in the library til midnight and are uneasy about walking a deserted campus alone
They are great to handle uncomplicated drunk and disorderly conduct
They can handle simple cases of vandalism and petty thievery
Maybe they can handle a fist fight between students
But the minute the (alleged or documented) conduct crosses over into something that, if true, would constitute a felony, then they're simply out of their league. They need immediately to refer the case to the city, county or state police-- in this case, to which ever police department has a dedicated sex crime unit.
Wow - thank you so much for your expert insights provided to us here. With so much going on right now I hadn't had the time to learn about this horror at Cornell U. SO MUCH wrong was done to this young woman.🥺😭 Let us hope that we as a society can bring her some sort of comfort. I'm going to share your piece on Facebook. We need to get the clear facts out to the public for the benefit of Jane Doe.
Thank you Mimi Rocah
This is a problem for the public whenever there is a criminal investigation.
In general, people want to compartmentalize facts, to form opinions, so they can process and move on, but that is not possible while an investigation is still early and ongoing. Even after, most information will not be widely available to the public.
That is why it is very important for police, prosecutors, and elected officials to be careful in their statements.
An early false impression, given with the weight of authority, is difficult to overcome, even if facts that contradict it are made available.
And the public needs to adjust the expectation of being able to know and form opinions right away.
All women should avoid going to frat houses, especially when intoxicated. There are so many of these incidents occuring in that setting. As far as I'm concerned fraternities are coddled and they should all be shut down.
It was my understanding, maybe in error, that she didn’t remember what had happened until later and to some extent through Snapchat, texts, or other social media exchanged by participants and seen by others. There’s no way she could know exactly what happened. She may have just dissociated like many victims do (as if she wasn’t really there, or it happened to someone else or not at all). Please clear this up for me. It would be that much worse if she learned later from shared social media rather than remembering herself later. Regardless, this will have a lasting effect on her life. I have seen 2 women who identified her rapist, and it went to trial, where the defense attorney tried to present it as her fault. ‘What were you wearing “ and the other accusations made in the body of this essay. Women who know how brutal a trial can be may not report it,