290 Comments
User's avatar
LiverpoolFCfan's avatar

" [Platner] announced he would pull out of the race, allowing the state party to devise a process for filling the vacancy".

Yes.

That's it.

He's out and now get someone better and get going to win this race.

Exactly what should have happened after the Access Hollywood comment came out in 2016.

Ivan Tufaart's avatar

The problem is that for the GQP, bad behavior is a feature, not a bug.

CharlesI's avatar

So it would seem. The Democrats have a stronger commitment to integrity and sense of propriety that this iteration of the Republican Party.

CE's avatar

Republicans don’t see sexual predators as a problem if they’re “electable”…..

David Ritchie's avatar

YES. The Republicans have no cause to celebrate the Platner debacle after they elected Trump - rape? check. Loves Fascists and dictators? Check. Plus pathological liar, cheat, and self-dealing.

KathrynW's avatar

We said the same exact thing at our house.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

Sadly, the media holds Republicans — especially Trump – to a different standard. And you do remember what happened right after those comments came out, right? There was a suspicious leak of material from Hillary's campaign insiders that many thought emanated from Russian hacks. And the media got distracted by this bright, shinty (although meaningless) thing, as Trump's backers, whoever they were, knew it would.

FVera's avatar

I never supported him and this does not surprise me in the least. And, the very idea that he would think he could choose his replacement. As Maya Angelou said, “when someone shows you who they are, believe them.”

Ivan Tufaart's avatar

Certainly the alarm bells were sounding for quite a while. It's a classic case of "drip...drip...drip....BOOM!"

It's enough to make me miss the smoke-filled room.

Ellen Bass's avatar

Well, he won the primary. Doesn't that give him the right to input on his replacement? Obviously he's a very flawed person and should be out, but do we "cancel" him?

Lisa Jean Walker's avatar

I’m glad that the Democratic Party is very clear that it doesn’t want or need an accused rapist to help pick their candidates. When men assault women, they disqualify themselves from having a say in the representation of women. He did this to himself. No one else is responsible. No, it doesn’t matter that he won the primary.

Simply Susan's avatar

Think of him as a husband you just divorced.

Would he have the right to input on his replacement?

Simply Susan's avatar

Sometimes we need to simplify these things, even dumb them down a bit.

Simply Susan's avatar

Thank you, Patricia. The voice of experience. 😉

Lee, Judith's avatar

He won votes on wish-fulfillment and a generous electorate’s assumption of innocence that has now eroded by the sheer number and of allegations. Democrats should not aspire to the cyclical ruthlessness that led the GOP and its voters to elect the damning evidence of the Access Hollywood tape, much less the convictions for fraud, defamation, and sexual assault in his home state of New York, where his sociopathy was on display for 50 years. Moreover, elections are a not service to the candidate; they are about service to the constituency, voters especially, but also the state, nation, and party. And with so much at stake for the party on whose platform he chose to run, it has a say, too—and they are not obligated to provide financial support.

Ned Harrison's avatar

Yeah...The voters wished they didn't have to choose between a 78 year old establishment centrist an a young flawed progressive sexist....

Gayle Logan's avatar

If you are talking about Susan Collins, she is NOT a centrist. She is a liar. She has always voted with the GOP and with T.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

Platner wasn't just "flawed" (the usual epithet applied to every woman who runs for higher office), he was tainted. And given the Massachusetts primary, I really don't want to hear anymore about age.

Wendy B.'s avatar

Elected officials never get to appoint their own replacements. The voters decide, or in certain weird situations, a governor appoints a replacement.

Ellen Bass's avatar

I never said he should select his replacement. Input is different.

Sheri Drisac's avatar

See above: Simply Susan's comment!!!

donna woodward's avatar

Demanding to have input into his replacement is the height of arrogance. And who knows what he might expect as a quid pro quo? Some position of power and perks? No, he has to go back to his oysters.

Hal's avatar

He won the primary, and I don't believe the Party can actually force him out, unless he signed some contract that had something like a "morals clause".

bitchybitchybitchy's avatar

DropnSite News was reporting before Platner dropped out that some Platner campaign workers were already working to find a candidate who would support at least some of Platner 's populist ideas.

Wendy B.'s avatar

Agree. When you find yourself engaging in mental acrobatics to excuse things about a candidate, there is something wrong there. While I don't expect humans to come without baggage, some things are just not excusable.

Potter's avatar

even if they reform, recover? had PTSD from 8+ years of war? even if they have good qualities?

This has happened before over sex- to Gary Hart, to Al Franken and others. *We* lose because we cannot forgive or give a chance to show growth. Meanwhile on the other side they keep on with the inexcusable, collecting "baggage" because they can. And they win.

Nona Faurnonce's avatar

I hear you, but there's more to it than that. If Platner had taken ownership of the things he did, thus demonstrating that he was a reformed character, that would be one thing. But, as Rubin pointed out, Platner never did take responsibility. The red flags have been all over the place for quite some time with him. Al Franken was quite a different case. It never really looked like he'd done more than used bad taste in some of his jokes as a professional comedian -- which IMO is true of practically every comedian out there.

Susan Berg's avatar

I guess Rubin never listened to the grilling MS NOW hosts Jen Psaki and Chris Hayes gave Platner early in his campaign. Hayes in particular asked very specific questions. Platner did own up. And also denied, as he continues to do, the more damning accusations.

Potter's avatar

The New York Times interviewed six women who had been romantically involved with Platner. Three spoke highly of him, while the other three described his behavior as "unsettling" and characterized their relationships with him as toxic or volatile.

Lyndsey Fifield told the Times that Platner became rough with her and sometimes left marks when he grabbed her by the shoulders during their two-year, on-again, off-again relationship. Fifield said he never punched, hit or injured her. She disclosed that she has worked for conservative groups.

In response to the allegations Platner said, "Throughout this campaign, I've been open about what was a very dark period of my life where I struggled with undiagnosed PTSD, too often self-medicated with alcohol, and was a far from perfect boyfriend. I take responsibility for all of that, and wish I had been better," in a statement to Maine's Total Coverage. "Any characterization beyond that is false, and I believe, politically motivated. I'm not proud of who I was then, but I am proud of the work I've done since, and the movement we are building in Maine."

Potter's avatar

Yes there have been "red flags" check about what and from who and why. Some women have their antennae so tuned that this is the most important thing, nothing mitigating it. Others including those in the party establishment as well as in the other party are just looking for this.

Stephen Brady's avatar

We have a large tent and represent a diverse cross section of the American population. We need to be able to present them and have vigorous debates about how to approach the depredations of tRump and the rethuglicans. Think about it! We have reformed and renovated Eisenhower Republicans like Adam Kinzinger and George Conway alongside Zorhan Mamdani and AOC. We have Ossoff. Warnock and Talarico bringing up the moral middle. They represent the best of us - what we are and speak to the new, improved Nation we seek and we should be proud to share a party with them!

Linda Mitchell, KCMO's avatar

I find it interesting that all of your heroes sport penises.

Kelly Rohrer's avatar

I don't think AOC sports a penis.

Linda Mitchell, KCMO's avatar

One out of how many? And I missed the reference to AOC since he used the actual names of the men. How about Tammy Baldwin? Elizabeth Warren? Kathy Hochul? All of the women who have been slogging in the back and who (except Warren who at least has the ear of NPR) are sidelined or dismissed when they present uncomfortable truths.

Ellen Bass's avatar

This is a column, not a thesis. Democrats should not have a quota of women. Ketanji Brown Jackson is a superlative SC justice, but she was unfairly diminished by Biden's statement that he would only consider black women. We need to avoid that sort of thing.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

Mentioning JUST AOC without the names of the numerous accomplished women in Congress is pretty thin. I know she's the prettiest and very outspoken, but when I look at what congresspeople like Melanie Stansbury, Shontel Brown, Becca Balint, Lauren Underwood and more are doing, they really deserve a shoutout too.

Mark D Olson's avatar

As does Graham Platner sport a penis. I took Mr. Brady's comment as a comparison to other males in politics that have managed their lives with integrity, not minimizing the women that have showed their moral and character integrity. I am not trying to put words in Mr. Brady's comments that aren't there. Off the top of my head I could name at least twenty women with moral and character integrity. For me, this is about Platner. I won't stick up for the MDP for a poor job of vetting Platner. But I for sure will not excuse Platner for his flat out dishonesty and lack of integrity he has displayed. It's a very bad time to be sloppy given what's at stake in this coming election. If the oligarchs let us have one.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

Those were different times. Also I don't think JFK was accused of rape.

Gayle Logan's avatar

The party does NOT get to choose the candidate. Bernie's voice is loud. Even Schumer wanting Mills to run brought screams from some in the party. Any citizen can theoretically choose to run.

Wendy B.'s avatar

Not true. The party does get to choose who represents them. Platner can still run: just not as a Democrat. As an independent. Anyone can run as an independent, or start their own party. But each party should have standards and should vet candidates very carefully before allowing them to represent the party.

bitchybitchybitchy's avatar

Susan Collins. Kristi Noem. Pam Bondi.

These three women are example that having female genitalia does not guarantee superior morality.

We have AOC, Nancy Pelosi, Christine Whitmer and other female politicians who have moderate/liberal/progressive cred

Stephen Brady's avatar

Really? Just what is AOC sporting. I also support Elizabeth Warren, Mary Peltola, and Deb Halland!

Potter's avatar

I find it interesting that you find it interesting. This is also where we are at.

Anca Vlasopolos's avatar

Thanks for this thorough analysis. Platner lost me at the Nazi tattoos. But then I'm the daughter of a mother who survived Auschwitz.

I Hate this Timeline's avatar

I believe top politicians (senate, gov. President) should come up through the ranks not because that's perfect but because working your way to the top is vetting stage two. What if trump had to start at school board, or even Congress? It's the self funded famous person catapult that is a disaster. That path ensues hubris and lank of voter experience with what they are voting for.

Gayle Logan's avatar

No thank you. Obama spent comparatively little time in the ranks. He was the best president that I have seen in my lifetime. Character, intelligence, ability to communicate, depth of knowledge, empathy, and understanding of government & history are the prerequisites for a president.

Charlie in VA's avatar

Illinois State Senate. U.S. Senate, POTUS.

Gayle Logan's avatar

True, thus I used the phrase "comparatively little time".

John DeLapp's avatar

Unfortunately, Eric Swalwell.

John-Manuel Andriote's avatar

Next time someone complains that “both” major political parties are “no different,” point out that while Democrats still abhor and drive away candidates (Platner, most recently) and even sitting officials (Al Franken) accused of sexual assault, Republicans choose to ignore sexual crimes and even elevate men (Trump) who boast of sexual assault to lead their party—and the country. That alone is a massive difference between practicing one’s values vs. merely proclaiming them.

Gayle Logan's avatar

The only reason that "the parties are the same" became a popular opinion is because news journalists repeated it regularly. Why have they been misinforming or lying to the public like this since Reagan? Because Reagan ended the Fairness Doc and the news media started replacing facts and evidence with opinions and beliefs. 95% of journalists have been increasingly in the pockets of GOP for many years. Scott Pelley alluded to it after leaving CBS. This did not start with Ellison & Weiss.

Steve 218's avatar

The 'news journalists' as you call them, are better referred to as media hacks. The real journalists were still speaking out and still are, though no longer on legacy media. The Fairness Doctrine would have to be re-written to cover all sources of the media. In its time, there was only the broadcast media to which it applied.

Gayle Logan's avatar

The 1st person I found who provided all the facts and evidence without bias was Heather Cox Richardson, a political historian.

The Fairness Doc applied to any news media - including newspapers.

Even those who left broadcast media failed to comment on the renewed racism OR the use of unregulated capitalism by every GOP admin since Reagan OR the lack of facts in mainstream news. They let the lies stand. They ignored the signs of Hitler's steps in GOP actions - starting with the Fairness Doc.

Jen Rubin left WAPO, but still holds on to a GOP bias and plays the blame game.

It is good that she is balanced by Ira Levin.

Signe K.'s avatar

The Fairness Doctrine is a complicated case. It’s fundamentally about presenting opposing viewpoints equally, so that uninformed americans can be presented with information. It is NOT actually about “facts.” Here’s one of many websites that discuss the Doctrine and possibilities for its revival and retooling: https://uslawexplained.com/fairness_doctrine

Steve 218's avatar

The Fairness Doctrine did not apply to newspapers. They aren't under the auspices of the FCC (Federal Communications Commission) which regulates broadcast media. Cable, satellite services and websites would not have been either as they didn't exist when the doctrine was enacted.

If you don't recognize that Jennifer Rubin has changed, too bad. You might also read what Dan Rather, an honorable journalist, still has to say.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

I don't believe she was "the first" although she does do a good job. She's not one of my chosen subscriptions because so many of her columns are historical, but if that's your interest, she does a good job.

Walter David Luce's avatar

Doesn't it strike all of you Contrarian readers of the unbelievable ability of us Americans to pontificate about Platner's unworthiness to be a Senator when our sitting POTUS is a convicted sex offender and a felon?? I mean what type of drug or poison have they put into the water to make us all so pitifully tolerant of djt. Why doesn't the Maine Democratic Party "Ask E Jean" or even Angus King the ethical independent Senator from Maine about the right thing to do here?

Don Kennedy's avatar

We are not all so tolerant of Trump, but as a member of the minority party at present, we are limited in what we can do.

Gayle Logan's avatar

We should be doing far more. WE HAVE MEN WOMEN & CHILDREN BEING TREATED CRUELLY IN CONCENTRATION CAMPS. Albanians otoh have been out in the streets for 30+ days to stop the Kushners from taking a part if their country.

Wendy B.'s avatar

Who says we tolerate him? Short of taking potshots at him, most of us have done everything in our power to get rid of him, now and before he was elected again.

Daniel Solomon's avatar

Out, out black spot....

Thomas Moore's avatar

Read the NYT article this morning about how Platner was selected, groomed, and his candidacy cultivated in the first place. That raises alarm bells about the whole process. A man selected for how his appeal could be manufactured rather than by what he had accomplished in public life.

Yes, it is also alarming how easily Dems fall into the circular firing squad.

Louise's avatar

You're correct but this is nothing at all new. And it is certainly not limited to Democrats. I seem to remember that the GOP powers-that-be picked Dan Quayle because they thought he was "handsome" and would appeal to female voters. And can we overlook Sarah Palin, chosen by the McCain campaign? Not sure exactly why. She was "cute"? Had nice legs? Wore those snazzy red shoes?

Ivan Tufaart's avatar

Last minute "fill in" candidates rarely do well at the polls, no matter how qualified they may be. Kamala Harris is a living example.

Beyond that all I can say is that Susan Collins was eminently beat-able, but her chances just improved a lot. She's got to be the luckiest human on the planet right now.

Daniel Solomon's avatar

Easy as ABC -- anbybody but Collins, aligned with Trump's position about 93% to 95% of the time.

patricia's avatar

sorry that woman really got raped of course, I am not a conspiracy person, but why did she come forward NOW instead of when platner was running ??? why now when he was probably going to win ??? we may have lost the senate in the wake of his crimes.

Signe K.'s avatar

The situation is complicated. Of course any rape allegation should be investigated. The judge and jury should NOT be social media, or posters on Substack. But I wonder, why is this woman being given far more credibility than the woman who testified about sexual assault by Bret Kavanaugh?

patricia's avatar

I do think women believed her...mostly men in confirming positions, xcpt collins

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

I think a lot of people believed that Christine Blasey Ford was credible — just not GOP Senators.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

We have not "lost the senate" because of Platner. I've been leaving him out of my calculations since the primary. Now? She said because although she was mentioned in The NY Times story, she was justifiably leery about sharing details, because women are ALWAYS trashed and disbelieved widely. But she saw the woman whose story led the NYT piece trashed and disbelieved because she was a Republican and felt that someone who was also a progress needed to step up.

Gayle Logan's avatar

Or Platner's candidacy had been enabled by the GOP.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

This is a radically different situation. We're talking about 700,000 voters as opposed to 154 million. And still a longer time frame.

Linda Mitchell, KCMO's avatar

The entire Platner debacle demonstrates that the Dems, almost as much as the Rethuglicans, want to sideline women when they present uncomfortable truths until the allegations become so revolting that they are forced to act. Far too many men are narcissist arseholes who think that women's bodies are always permeable and that they can get away with it simply because [1] they always have, and [b] they are confident that the women will be scoffed at, belittled, and ridiculed. It is far past time for all of us to rise up and demand that ovaries as well as penises have a real seat at the table as equal partners. Remember: 53% of the American population is female. We outnumber the boyz. And the sexual harassment and assaults women routinely experience (and the numbers of actual cases of both are far, far higher than the reported cases--I challenge any woman to deny that they have experienced one and/or the other) must be acknowledged and MEN taught to behave themselves.

Robert Lastick's avatar

We have given our country away to Autocratic Fascists.

I see many who care little.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

I think it's interesting that Platner was romanced by out of-state consultants who told him he was a "hero" and a "historical figure." I think he was gullible enough to fall for it.

James McConnel's avatar

The life of a Democracy involves agreeing, disagreeing, and making compromises. It does not involve kneeling or genuflecting. Those looking for that kind of government have found it in the Trump Regime. Soon we will make that Regime a thing of the unpleasant past.

Steve 218's avatar

From your lips....As long as we don't get sidtracked in the mire of propaganda, and keep working for our liberties and freedoms, we will defeat this abomination.

Jason's avatar

I am more optimistic on how this will turn out than many here are.

This isn't the same as Harris after Biden, this is race in a sparsely populated, largely homogeneous state with a unique and tightly knit culture overall, where the incumbent remains very unpopular and will be tied to Trump's endless failures no matter what she does, in a year that is heavily favoring Democratic challengers, the opposite of 2024.

And now, Maine has a chance to have an actual competition for the nomination, even if it in every short time, as opposed to Schumer's strategy of pushing an uninspiring candidate who would have been 85 by the end of her term if she would have won (another examples of Schumer's 'leadership' - this factor in Platner's rise is still being glossed over). The leading candidates so far are all well known to Mainers and IMO a few of them have a very good chance at beating Collins.

If anything good came from Platner's campaign, it's that he has shown what Maine Dem voters want to see. Like many Democratic voters everywhere, they want a real fight against AI and crypto takeover, against billionaire power and PAC influence, against genocide, and for public health care, affordability, and a humane and just immigration system. Platner's message resonated - he was the wrong messenger.

It's also fortunate at least that Platner pulled out now with only days left until it would have been too late. There's nothing good about these allegations of course, he absolutely needed to go. But it could have been worse if the Dems were stuck with him after these latest charges became public (or , maybe even if these latest charges hadn't become public at all, he was already sliding in polls).

Sandy's avatar

As a woman, I think rape abhorrent. I would not want it to happen to myself, my daughter, or my granddaughters, or any other woman. I see, however, a country so hypoocritical that it would elect a President who has been accused and found guilty of similar allegations - who, even when ordered by a court to pay up the fines he was found liable for, refuses to to date to pay the woman in question. Like Platner, he claims he was not guilty. Yet he was elected President - our moral leader.

Adrienne Auryansen's avatar

There was a lot of negative information about him out there for a while. I find it hard to give kudos to his party backers now that they having an oh no moment , in light of all that. I find it difficult to believe that this came as a surprise to them.

Thomas Kraus's avatar

I agree that Platner needed to withdraw. But what about Corey Booker? He has supported the killing of 10's of thousands of Palestinian women. Surely that should disqualifying him too.

Jason's avatar

You could say the same of much of the Dem leadership.

Gayle Logan's avatar

WHY do you think that ONLY dems are involved with AIPAC?

Jason's avatar

1. who said anything about AIPAC? 2. This convo is about the Democratic Party and its candidates, if you hadn't noticed 3. The GOP is beyond redemption, which is obvious to most people reading here.

Gayle Logan's avatar

You are equating votes on policy to killing AND BLAMING ONLY the DEMOCRATS? GOP members have ALSO been aided by AIPAC, The entire GOP & GOP MOC are still in control and have spent $103B so far in bombing (at NETANYAHU's request) to aid N's war on Gaza & Lebanon. DO SOME RESEARCH and find out just how much AIPAC has been entangled in and influenced our government for DECADES. I was astonished. AIPAC itself is NOT just 1 organization. There are 100's of AIPAC pacs in the US.

Jason's avatar

While you are WRITING IN ALL CAPS as if that helps make your point, note that these are comments about an article explicitly and entirely focused on Democrats.

Note also that you are the only person to even mention AIPAC. The initial comment was about the long term Democratic support for mass killings of Palestinians, which is indisputable. Israel's genocide and apartheid was fully funded and politically supported by Biden and virtually all the elected Democratic leadership for 15 months (and before that really), and still continues.

If it necessary to add in the GOP< ok yes the GOP has supported genocide too. Happy? That is obvious and well known to Contrarian readers...what is less obvious and much less mentioned here is the full support given by much of the Democratic Party, despite what its base supports.

patricia's avatar

really, why go there

Jason's avatar

It's pretty obvious. The notion of scandal, or red lines, is incredibly subjective., and not just with the GOP that has no lines at all.

Platner needed to go, no doubt, as did Eric Swalwell...and of course, trump never should have been near the WH,.

But when both leading GOP and Dem officials openly , enthusiastically, emphatically support the mass murder of men, women and children with financial, military and political support...is this a 'scandal' or just regular ol politics? Why are these leaders not forcefully condemned for supporting such horrible crimes, that continue to this day?

This is also (again, obviously ) relevant because this support for genocide has enraged Democrats voter across the country. Being firmly against genocide shouldn't be a high bar, but apparently it is for many.

patricia's avatar

edited for spelling

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

OFFS. That is them most absurd and baseless claim yet from the so-called "pro-Palestinian" movement. I could say anyone who squawks "AIPAC AIPAC" at any candidate they don't like is an anti-Semite and should shut up and go away. It would make as much sense. Sheesh.

Marliss Desens's avatar

One important point that Jen does not cover is the role of an outside the state political group that chose and promoted Platner. That group, run by Dan Moraff created Platner's candidacy and image as "working class," although he comes from what would be considered a privileged background. Moraff did not want to pay for an in-depth background check. You can find reporting on Moraff in the NYT, WSJ, and National Review. A political consultant class that wants to win at any price is part of our problem.

Marliss Desens's avatar

Liza Donnely also gives a good overview in her Substack "Seeing Things" today.