125 Comments
User's avatar
JudiLI's avatar

The Democrats leadership needs to read the room. The voters have spoken and they want new leadership

Sue Connaughton's avatar

I agree and also believe that Jeffries is not up to the job. Eleven of his members missed the Hegseth impeachment vote. He has not been a strong minority leader.

Pam Birkenfeld's avatar

I agree, but that’s not going to be easy because having the first black speaker in the House of representatives is a powerful message. That all the wonderful black women and men who carried us over the line on this election are going to expect that, I think.

Mo Khan's avatar

Draft Ayanna Presley

Hal's avatar

"The Democrats leadership needs to read the room. The voters have spoken and they want new leadership"

The Dems certainly need to "read the room". Unfortunately, they are not one monolithic bloc that reads and interprets things in the same manner. Above all, the Dems, in general, need to accept that they "won" because voters were fed up with Republican rule for the past two years. It does not follow that voters are enamored of Democrats or their policies. If they were, the Dems would not have lost the WH and Senate in 2024.

Hiro's avatar

"Moreover, especially for the party that does not hold the presidency, its congressional leaders become its personification." This is the key insight. The majority leader should be competing with Trump on the same platform to win prsidency in 2028.

Jason's avatar
5hEdited

Yet another reason to replace Schumer is his support for fast tracking BAAJA.

There's a reason a majority of Democratic Senators, the ACLU, virtually every national environmental group, anti-ICE groups, the NAACP, tribal groups and so many others are firmly against BAAJA: it is a wish list for AI data center proliferation.

BAAJA will implement the polar opposite of what voters across the country clearly voted for regarding data centers. It is wholeheartedly backed by big tech and big oil. This bill will effectively nullify the Endangered Species Act.

It also explains why Charles Schumer joined nearly all Republicans (along with 20 other Democrats) is supporting the fast tracking of this awful bill ...knowing it will never get past the incoming Democratic Congress...just one more reason to replace Schumer as Senate Dem leader.

From the AI Now Institute:

'BAAJA functions as a “backdoor bailout”: enacting legal changes that will speed up and expand access to the industry’s biggest constraint—power—despite unacceptable costs to our economy, democracy, and environment. BAAJA helps AI companies double down on their speculative bets.

BAAJA also insulates an already unaccountable AI industry from pushback, serving hyperscale data center developers at the expense of local, state, and Tribal authorities. At a moment in which communities across the country and of diverse ideological leanings are scrutinizing the impacts of data centers on their economic and environmental futures, BAAJA would strip them of key tools that empower them to slow or reject the construction of data centers in their communities.....

Seventeen state attorneys general have raised urgent concerns that BAAJA undermines local, state, and Tribal authorities, despite recent amendments. The bill preempts local, state, and Tribal decision making over data center projects by weakening their authority to protect natural and cultural resources under the Clean Water Act, the National Historic Preservation Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, and the Endangered Species Act.'

Jason's avatar
5hEdited

Oh forgot to add - Van Hollen is opposed to BAAJA.

And another point in his favor:

Schumer voted in favor of reality TV star Sean Duffy for Secretary of Transportation.

Van Hollen did not.

Leu2500's avatar

not a single one of the felon's nominees, not even Rubio, should have received a single Democratic vote.

Mark Pukey's avatar

Agreed. There is a tradition that a President should have the cabinet they want to work with. That's fine. But the Senate's actual job is to ensure these nominees are capable of doing the job! Voting for people like Duffy, who was clearly not ready for the role, was the wrong move.

Stephen Brady's avatar

Schumer is an old-guard politico who is not what We The People need. We are at a potential inflection point in our Nation's history. It is going to take bold, decisive, energetic people to pull us back from the brink.

bruce glick's avatar

20 Senate Democrats, including Schumer and other big-name Senators, have joinied with Republicans to advance the BAAJA. It seems that the Democrats are already giving away their mandate before they even have the majority. And with Jeffrey’s lackluster leadership in the House re; Hegseth’s impeachment vote and his pre-election meeting with a Trump family member, things are not off to a promising start.

Jason's avatar
5hEdited

Note that this is still a minority of Senate Democrats..so there's still hope.

It seems really obvious they are fast tracking this because they know that nearly all (maybe all) of the incoming Senators will probably all be opposed to this.

Cam Ranalli's avatar

Write your House member urging them to vote no on this Bill. That is the only hope we have now of stopping this. ANY bill sponsored by Capito is bound to be a stinker.

HARRIET SCHETZSLE's avatar

And Mike Lee who has a 3% approval from The League of Conservation Voters.

donna woodward's avatar

Thank you, Jen, for a great exposition. Schumer is not the leader we need or want. The secret ballot may end up being our friend.

William Schrader's avatar

Very well written article. All you have to remember is how Schumer handled January 6th till he let it fade away. He simply doesn't have the strength. And I am tired of the reason he should be in charge is because he raises money. Fund raising isn't a quality for leadership it is a quality for being hired by the DNC. We can't afford to not show the American people that we got their message. And I don't care if he promises to not run in the future that is what primaries are for.

Douglas W Mendenhall's avatar

Past time for Shummer to go…this is a unique opportunity to move the party forward and capitalize on the momentum for change.

Milford Sprecher's avatar

An excellent overview of the stakes.

Van Hollen was involved with candidate recruitment when he was in the House, so he knows how to do that. He may not be as big a fundraiser by not running to AIPAC, but grassroots fundraising is becoming more important. He is my senator and I have always found him to be very engaging, a good listener and someone who will stand up for what he believes in.

Steve 218's avatar

As we have seen in several of the last races, money didn't buy the votes that the donor(s) intended. In fact, it's beginning to look like people are finally getting the idea that big money (and its interests) should no longer be so influential in politics.

Anne Pierce's avatar

I'm afraid Senator Schumer does not realize how extremely unpopular the Netanyahu government is with voters. The new Majority Leader needs to be willing to end military assistance to Israel. Also, as posted below, data centers are a massive pain point all over the country. The last thing we need is to make their construction faster and easier.

Jane in NC's avatar

Schumer himself isn't popular with the American public either. An Economist/YouGov poll from early November showed him with a negative 31 point approval; for perspective Donald Trump was at negative 21.

Jane in NC's avatar

Shocking, eh? Neither Schumer nor Jeffries have any reason to be on their high horse.

Dawn's avatar

I agree completely. Schumer is not in touch with the main issues that drove our historic wins across the nation. We need to get money out of politics--people are completely fed up with money's corrupting power in our system. Schumer is a "corporate Democrat." We voted for the ones who said they would not take corporation's bribes. And then the main issue is addressing the shocking level of income inequality in our country through aggressive legislation. We need tax reform to address wealth concentration and the favoring of capital over labor. We need to fully staff the IRS and emphasize prosecuting tax cheats. We need to secure the future of Social Security as for far too many Americans it is the ONLY pension for old age. And we need to fix our broken health care system by moving towards Medicare for all as quickly as is feasible. No more nibbling around the edges. We are looking for a new deal for the 21st century. That calls for new leadership from the party.

Caroline Kenna's avatar

The clock is ticking Dems must show not tell that this is the party of the people. New Senate leadership is a start!

donna woodward's avatar

Yes. That should have been obvious. And it was, to Van Hollen. Not to Schumer.

Alyce Bergbower's avatar

Thank you for clearing pointing out these myths. If we want change, we need Van Hollen. If we want the status quo, then it is Schumer. The best predictor of future behavior is past behavior. Schumer’s record is not stellar and he has capitulated to Trump and trumpism way too much!! It is time for all Senators to grow a spine as well and choose CHANGE!! That is what the people voted for in this election. To do that you have to unshackle the chains of the status quo and the “this is how we do things here” mentality.

Sara P's avatar

Schumer needs to go. Thanks for laying out the reasons.

Hal's avatar

"Schumer needs to go. Thanks for laying out the reasons."

Jen keeps "laying out the reasons" for Schumer's departure, but there's no "laying out the reasons" why Van Hollen should be Schumer's replacement.

Chris Dortch's avatar

Many have said it, but it bears repeating. The blue tsunami, exactly two weeks in the making, was an audition, not a mandate. It swept in new leaders of all descriptions, but the common thread among them is they know our system is rigged against their constituents. They're eager to right that wrong. To do that, aggressive leadership is needed. Chris Van Holland should be the new Senate Majority Leader. There's not a minute to waste as the Democrats undo the untold damage wrought by Trump and his goons.

Steve 218's avatar

The name is 'Van Hollen' but otherwise, right on the money with your post. The last election points to the fact that "the way we've always done it" is no longer what we need.

Janete's avatar

Schumer favors the interests of corporate donors as much as or more than real people.

Van Hollen promises to favor US. Americans desperately needs a leader who is fighting for them.

This election was about the monied vs. the many. For once, the many won and we want a leader who understands the stakes: you do not defeat fascism through appeasement. Thank you for your service, Chuck. Please sit down.

Linda P's avatar

Was it not Nancy Pelosi who steered the Affordable Care Act?

She at least deserves a mention for her mastery of the job especially during Trump 1.0

Anne Pierce's avatar

Her work in the House was extraordinary. She is one of the greatest Speakers ever.

mary thiel's avatar

And yet, why did she anoint Jeffries as her successor?

Maureen Dorsey's avatar

To make herself look even better?? He is a cure for insomnia.

Margaret Reis's avatar

Good, important article!

Leu2500's avatar

The World Series manager thing is nonsense.

Schumer personifies "this is the way we've always done things." Well, we tried that during Biden's admin. How'd that work out? "the way we've always done things" is inadequate to meet the emergency our democracy is in.